8 Margaret's Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

New Construction Waterfront with Dock

Set on 1.05± acres along the shores of West Neck Creek, 8 Margaret's Drive presents a newly constructed waterfront residence designed to embrace the natural beauty and relaxed character of Shelter Island. With direct frontage along the creek and a thoughtful orientation toward the water, the property brings together refined new construction, generous outdoor living, and a private waterfront setting. Built by Mark Lumley Contracting Corp. with architecture by London Architecture + Design, the residence offers approximately 4,250 square feet of interior living space across the main house and finished space above the detached two-car garage. The floor plan provides six bedrooms in the main residence, complemented by a separate office and full bath above the garage - creating a versatile additional space removed from the primary living areas. Inside, wide-plank white oak flooring and a restrained material palette establish a warm, understated character throughout. The main living level is organized around an open kitchen, dining room, and living room, with expansive areas for gathering and a natural connection to the surrounding decks and landscape. The custom kitchen is appointed with Cloud White cabinetry with natural walnut interiors, Nica quartzite countertops and backsplash, and a complete Sub-Zero, Wolf, and Cove appliance package. Custom TruStile interior doors, Marvin windows and sliding doors, and polished nickel hardware and fixtures continue the considered detailing throughout the home. The bedroom layout offers flexibility across both levels, culminating in a private second-floor primary suite with a walk-in closet and generously appointed bath. Bathrooms throughout feature Kohler and Samuel Heath fixtures, frameless low-iron glass shower enclosures, and radiant heated floors, while the primary bath adds a freestanding tub and elevated Samuel Heath fittings. Outdoors, the property has been conceived around its waterfront setting. Mahogany decking surrounds the residence, while an expansive activity lawn and 15' x 48' saltwater gunite pool with an upgraded Pebble Tec finish create a natural extension of the interiors. Existing trees and mature vegetation are complemented by native plantings, understated pathways, and open lawn, allowing the landscape to retain an organic quality as it transitions toward the shoreline of West Neck Creek. Behind the finishes, the residence has been designed with equally considered infrastructure, including multi-zone heating and cooling, whole-home humidification and MERV-13 filtration, Lutron RadioRA lighting controls in common spaces, structured wiring for whole-house audio/video, comprehensive security and water-monitoring systems, and a 26 kW automatic standby generator. 8 Margaret's Drive offers a rare opportunity to experience new construction directly on West Neck Creek-combining a substantial waterfront parcel, sophisticated design, and a relaxed indoor-outdoor lifestyle in one of Shelter Island's most naturally beautiful settings.